We speak English, Punjabi & Hindi.
Murder and Attempted Murder
Murder, attempted murder, and manslaughter are some of the most serious criminal
charges in Canada. These offences can lead to lengthy jail sentences, potentially resulting
in life imprisonment. Individuals facing murder or manslaughter charges must carefully
consider the lawyer they choose to assist them in this most serious matter.
Canadian law acknowledges different degrees of culpability within the spectrum of
homicide, dividing it into three subcategories: first-degree murder, second-degree
murder, and manslaughter. Each subcategory reflects the alleged offender’s level of
responsibility in the death.
First-degree murder involves a planned and deliberate killing. Planning implies the
conception and thoughtful consideration before execution, and deliberation involves
intentional and purposeful acts. The plan need not be elaborate; what matters is the
deliberate execution of the plan. An unsuccessful plan to kill may result in attempted
murder. Certain circumstances can categorize a homicide as first-degree murder,
regardless of planning. Murdering a police officer is always considered first-degree
murder, assuming the accused knew the person was a police officer. Additionally, a
murder committed during specific offenses like hijacking, sexual assault, terrorism, or on
behalf of a criminal organization is deemed first-degree murder.
Second-degree murder encompasses any murder that is not first-degree murder. It
includes intentional homicides not falling under the specific categories of first-degree
murder.
Any culpable homicide not meeting the criteria for murder is manslaughter. Since
“murder” involves intentional killing, any murder committed without the intent to kill is
manslaughter. The common types include unlawful act manslaughter and manslaughter by
criminal negligence.
Defences for murder and related offences
Factual Innocence: If the Crown fails to prove the essential elements of the specific offense beyond a reasonable doubt, they have not met their burden, leading to an acquittal for the accused.
Factual Innocence: If the Crown fails to prove the essential elements of the specific offense beyond a reasonable doubt, they have not met their burden, leading to an acquittal for the accused.
Self-Defence:
Certain circumstances may justify one's actions, particularly when
protecting oneself or others. To successfully argue self-defence, it must be demonstrated
that:
- There were reasonable grounds to believe that the accused or others faced the risk of force or the threat of force.
- The accused's actions were committed with the purpose of defending or protecting themselves or someone else.
- The actions taken were reasonable considering the circumstances.
Automatism:
Automatism can be asserted as a defense in rare instances, involving
unconscious and involuntary behavior. Causes may include sleep disorders, head injuries,
or the involuntary consumption of illicit substances.
Mental Disorder:
If someone is found not criminally responsible due to a mental disorder,
they are still considered guilty of the act but lacked the required mental intention.
Provocation:
A partial defense of provocation exists. In cases of intentional killing under
circumstances involving provocation or severe intoxication, a defense of provocation or
intoxication may be presented. However, under current legal standards, murder cases are
infrequently reduced to manslaughter due to provocation or intoxication.
What are the sentences for murder and manslaughter?
While the distinctions between first-degree murder, second-degree murder, and manslaughter aim to differentiate more and less blameworthy behavior, all three offenses carry serious penalties. Individuals found guilty of first or second-degree murder automatically face life imprisonment. Parole eligibility varies, with a minimum of 25 years for first-degree murder and generally 10 years for second-degree murder. The parole ineligibility period can be increased up to 25 years at the judge’s discretion.
While the distinctions between first-degree murder, second-degree murder, and manslaughter aim to differentiate more and less blameworthy behavior, all three offenses carry serious penalties. Individuals found guilty of first or second-degree murder automatically face life imprisonment. Parole eligibility varies, with a minimum of 25 years for first-degree murder and generally 10 years for second-degree murder. The parole ineligibility period can be increased up to 25 years at the judge’s discretion.
For manslaughter, the least culpable type of homicide, the maximum penalty is life
imprisonment. If committed using a firearm, there’s a minimum sentence of four years. In
other cases, the penalty is at the discretion of the trial judge, with no minimum sentence.
For more information on murder and other related offences, contact us now.
GET FREE LEGAL
Consultant
Reach out to us now to schedule a complimentary legal consultation and let our experienced team provide you with the guidance you need.